Herbicide Control

Mix Together Effective Sites of Action to Decrease Herbicide Resistance Development

Growers have relied on herbicides as the main tool for managing weeds in grain crops, preventing weeds from reducing yields and interfering with crop management and harvest.  Reliance on the same or similar herbicides has resulted in weed biotypes evolving resistance to herbicides. Herbicide-resistant weed biotypes are no longer controlled by herbicides that previously killed them.  New strategies are necessary to control these resistant biotypes.  It is important to prevent herbicide-resistant weed biotypes from developing in the first place.

Reducing the risk of developing herbicide-resistant biotypes requires an integrated approach to weed control (IWM). Integrating prevention, mechanical, cultural, and biological as well as strategic chemical control is necessary to forestall herbicide resistance. When it comes to chemical weed control, farmers are hearing about rotating and diversifying herbicides, but the concept is often not explained.

Managing herbicide resistance requires an understanding of herbicide site of action. Herbicide containers and labels now display a herbicide group number that identifies the site of action. While using different and multiple herbicide site of action is important, understanding how to use “effective herbicide site of action” is critical for addressing herbicide resistance.


Click here to read more on herbicide effective site of action and how to implement an effective herbicide program,

1st video: Effective Site of Action and How it Should Be Used.



2nd video:  “Should I Rotate Herbicides or Tank Mix Them?”

Research from past few years has shed light on how important it is to tankmix herbicides compared to rotating herbicides.

In this video, Dr. Patrick Tranel explains his farm-based survey of over 100 Illinois farmers who tank mixed herbicides compared to using them in sequence. This video explains why tank mixing herbicides is the best option to practice and encourages farmers and professionals to select at least two “Effective Site of Action Herbicides” as a consistent strategy for weed resistance management.


3rd video: A Deep-Dive into Tank Mixing Herbicides Compared to Rotating Them

Dr. Tranel explains why tank mixing is a more effective approach to resistance management than sequential applications.

Assuming resistance is already in the field, even when not detected due to low levels (year 1 to 7 on the graph), farmers should manage resistance while still being in the “Resistance management” phase (graph#1). In this phase, herbicide resistance frequency is lower than 1% and often is not visible in the field.

At that stage, we can still manage the frequency of resistance, and prevent these weeds from becoming problematic. Without resistance management tactics, the frequency of resistance can increase rapidly. This is when weeds will become very noticeable in the field and it will be difficult to manage the now resistant weed population (“Too late phase in Graph#1).

Graph#1: Resistance evolution

Evolution of resistance over time results from repeated used of a single herbicide to which a weed population was not previously exposed. The y-axis shows the frequency of plants in the field that are resistant to the herbicide; note that, when plotted on a log scale, there is a linear increase in resistance. Once resistance in the field becomes apparent to the farmer (>1% of the plants are resistant), the evolutionary process has essentially played out, and it is too late to manage resistance. Resistance management strategies should be implemented beginning with the very first application of a new herbicide.

Herbicide management appears to be the most important factor contributing to weed resistance.

Questions such as “does management affect resistance or does resistance influence management?” are covered in this video to help farmers understand what they can do to prevent this problem.


Herbicide Classification Chart, 

Featured Image: A plant cuticule, which is the first place a herbicide hits in order to reach the different “Sites of Action”. Pics: Claudio Rubione


Video contents:

Patrick Tranel, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, IL

Mark VanGessel, University of Delaware, Georgetown, DE

Michael Flessner, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA

Bob Hartzler, Iowa State University, Ames, IA

Claudio Rubione, University of Delaware, Georgetown, DE


1st video:

Claudio Rubione, Mark VanGessel, Victoria Ackroyd and Michael Flessner

2nd video: 

Claudio Rubione and Patrick Tranel

3rd video:

Webinar footage provided courtesy of WeedSmart, to watch original and complete version visit: WEBINAR 

Video edits: Claudio Rubione